First Vote on Banking Royal Commission Recommendation: Senator Patrick to Move Amendment to End Grandfathered Conflicted Remuneration

11 February 2019

The Senate will have its first opportunity tomorrow to vote on one of Commissioner Hayne’s 76 recommendations.

The Banking Royal Commission highlighted millions of dollars in conflicted remuneration were still being paid in return for no advice. This is completely unacceptable.

Commissioner Hayne stated in his final report:

“In the Interim Report, I posed the following question: If the premise for the conflicted remuneration provisions is accepted (and no‑one suggested that it should not be) how can the grandfathering provisions be justified today? In my view, the answer to that question is now clear: they cannot.”

“For grandfathered commissions, the time when the initial advice was given and the initial conflict arose has passed. The influence of the commission has already done its work once. But the problem remains. The influence continues. Advisers have an incentive to keep their clients in products with grandfathered commissions rather than advise them to move to better products. There can be, and is, no justification for maintaining the grandfathering provisions.”

This recommendation been accepted by both the Government and the Labor Party.

The Government has said they will end grandfathered commissions with a timetable for removal of 1 January 2021. Labor has said it should be now.

Senator Patrick’s bill, which was released for comment on 1 October 2018 and forms the basis for the amendment, has a date of 1 July 2020. This is an appropriate transition time and a compromise between Labor’s proposed time frame and that of the Government's.

“The sunset on grandfathered commissions will act as an incentive for advisers to engage with their clients and move them out of those products. In practice, the amount may be quite small by 1 July 2020 but that would mean the law has done its job," said Rex.

The amendment will phase out grandfathered conflicted remuneration by 1 July 2020 and ensure that the value of any payments made after this date are rebated to clients.

A copy of the amendment can be found here.

Major Parties Fail to Stand Up For Julian Assange and Freedom of the Press
12 April 2019
"Labor leader Bill Shorten’s response to the arrest and prospective extradition of Wikileaks publisher Julian Assange stands in sharp contrast to that of his British...
Read More
Ships Shame Subs and Government on Local Content
11 April 2019
Further evidence that the Coalition Government’s failure on Future Submarine local content has been heard at Senate Estimates after questioning of the Defence Department by...
Read More
Arrest of Julian Assange
11 April 2019
"Mr Assange should be subject to the due process of the British legal system and, in the absence of any other legal matters, be allowed...
Read More
Eyre Peninsula Freight Plan Off the Rails: Eyre Peninsula Citizens Abandoned by Government
9 April 2019
Centre Alliance Senator Rex Patrick has described yesterday’s release of the ‘Eyre Peninsula Freight Strategy’ as both a deceit to the people of the Port...
Read More